18 Sep Antigua Resort Review: Cocobay vs Keyonna
A huge thanks to our great clients for sharing this review with us! We love getting firsthand feedback like this because it helps bring these resorts to life in a way photos and brochures just can’t. Our clients recently stayed at Keyonna Beach Resort in 2024 and Cocobay Resort in 2025. Both trips were wonderful but very different experiences. Let’s take a look at everything they had to say about each one.
Antigua Resort Review: Cocobay vs Keyonna Beach
Cocobay Resort Antigua
At Cocobay, they stayed in a Premium Pool Suite. The setting was beautiful with colorful cottages, ocean views, and lots of charm. They loved the staff, stating that they were some of the friendliest people they have ever met. The coffee shop and gym were nice touches, and the guided nature walk and Hobie Cat sailing tour were highlights. Meals were tasty and varied at lunch and dinner, and the main bar was a fun spot to relax.
On the downside, the beach wasn’t very welcoming, and the beach pool wasn’t well-maintained. The main pool had gorgeous views but tended to be crowded. Their bathroom was hot and lacked privacy, and storage space in the room was limited. They said Cocobay was perfect for a shorter three to four-night stay, but not where they’d spend a whole week.
Keyonna Beach Resort Antigua
Keyonna, on the other hand, was one of their favorite resorts ever. Their Beachfront Sanctuary Pool Cottage came with a private plunge pool, hammock, cabana, and direct beach access. Everything was ocean-facing and breathtaking. They loved the top-shelf liquor, daily stocked minibar, reusable water bottles, and the outdoor shower. The food was consistently good, with local favorites like jerk chicken and beef patties at the grill, and the whole atmosphere felt calm and romantic.
The only negatives at Keyonna were that the staff didn’t feel quite as warm as Cocobay, and the bar area was small. There’s also no gym or coffee shop, but overall, they would go back for a full week in a heartbeat.
Our takeaway is that Cocobay is fun, social, and full of character – plus the staff is unforgettable – while Keyonna is peaceful, romantic, and made for longer stays. Both have their charm, but for this client, Keyonna came out on top.
Which Antigua resort would you visit? Let’s start planning your next Caribbean island adventure!
Enchanted Honeymoons Travel | Antigua Resorts & Spas | Caribbean Island Resort Reviews
Call us today to speak to one of our Antigua Travel Specialists. You can reach us at 402-390-9291. In addition, you can get started here.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Are travel agents worth it?
Yes! A travel agent takes the stress out of planning by handling the details, finding the best packages, and giving you insider recommendations. Plus, they’re there to help if any issues come up during your trip, which is something you don’t get when booking online on your own.
2. Is it more expensive to use a travel agent?
No. Our travel agents are paid by the tour companies and resorts that we book through. We do not charge service fees. Our services are completely free to you!
3. Which resort is the best in Antigua?
It depends on what you’re looking for! Cocobay and Keyonna are two of our top recommendations for couples. They are both all-inclusive, adults-only, and perfect for romance. For larger properties with more activities, resorts like Sandals Grande Antigua are also favorites.
4. Where is Antigua located?
Antigua is part of the Caribbean and sits in the West Indies. It’s one of the two main islands that make up the country of Antigua and Barbuda, located east of St. Kitts and just north of Guadeloupe.
5. What are the most popular Caribbean travel destinations?
The Caribbean is full of amazing options! Some of the most popular spots include Jamaica, the Dominican Republic, St. Lucia, the Bahamas, and Antigua. Each island has its own unique culture, beaches, and resort experiences.
6. What is the best all-inclusive in Antigua?
Sandals Grande Antigua is often ranked as one of the best all-inclusive resorts on the island, especially for honeymoons. But for boutique, adults-only stays, Cocobay and Keyonna are also incredible choices.
7. What is the best all-inclusive in the Caribbean?
There’s no single “best” since it depends on your style of travel. Popular picks include Sandals resorts across several islands, Excellence resorts in the Dominican Republic, and boutique gems like Jade Mountain in St. Lucia. For couples, Cocobay and Keyonna in Antigua are also standouts.
8. Do you need a passport to go to Antigua?
Yes, U.S. citizens need a valid passport to travel to Antigua.
9. What is the best time of year to visit Antigua?
The most popular time is December through April for warm, dry weather. However, May through November can be a great value with fewer crowds and lower rates.
10. Is Antigua safe for tourists.
Yes, Antigua is generally very safe for tourists, especially in resort areas.